First time at Zeet?

13 Mar
min read

Complete Comparison of Terraform vs Cloudformation (2024)

Terraform vs Cloudformation: Which is right for you? This analysis breaks down the differences between the two infrastructure management tools.

Jack Dwyer

Platform Engineering + DevOps

Share this article

What Is Terraform?

terraform service managing resources - Terraform vs Cloudformation

To help you navigate your choice between Terraform vs Cloudformation, let's start by understanding what is Terraform to guide you toward the ideal solution for your infrastructure management.

Terraform is an open-source infrastructure as code software tool created by HashiCorp. It allows users to define and provision data center infrastructure using a declarative configuration language. With Terraform, you can manage a variety of cloud services and on-premises infrastructure by writing code. This code, written in HashiCorp Configuration Language (HCL), describes the desired state of the infrastructure, and Terraform takes care of provisioning and managing the resources to achieve that state. 

How does Terraform differ from Cloudformation?

Terraform and AWS CloudFormation are both infrastructure as code tools, but they have some key differences. While CloudFormation is specific to AWS, Terraform is cloud-agnostic, meaning it can be used to manage resources on multiple cloud platforms like AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, and others. 

This makes Terraform a more versatile choice for organizations with multi-cloud environments. Terraform uses a declarative syntax, allowing users to define the desired end state without specifying the exact sequence of steps to get there. In contrast, CloudFormation uses an imperative approach, where users must define the sequence of steps to reach the desired state.

What are the benefits of using Terraform over Cloudformation?

One of the main benefits of using Terraform over CloudFormation is its cloud-agnostic nature. With Terraform, you can manage resources across different cloud providers using a single tool and configuration. This flexibility is especially valuable for organizations that have a multi-cloud strategy or are considering using multiple cloud platforms. 

Terraform's declarative syntax allows for easier collaboration and version control of infrastructure code. Since Terraform code describes the desired end state, it is less prone to errors caused by manual intervention or misconfigurations. Lastly, Terraform's vibrant community and extensive provider ecosystem provide users with a wide range of resources, modules, and integrations to leverage in their infrastructure management processes.

Related Reading

What Is Cloudformation?

how AWS cloudformation works - Terraform vs Cloudformation

CloudFormation is a service provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS) that allows you to define and provision your AWS infrastructure as code. This means you can create templates using JSON or YAML to describe the resources needed for your application or workload, such as EC2 instances, VPCs, S3 buckets, and more. 

When you deploy a CloudFormation stack, AWS will automatically create, update, or delete the resources as specified in your template, ensuring consistency and reproducibility in your infrastructure.

Key Features of Cloudformation

One of the key features of CloudFormation is the ability to manage dependencies between resources. You can define the order in which resources are created, ensuring that they are provisioned in the correct sequence. CloudFormation also supports parameterization, allowing you to pass in dynamic values at runtime, making your templates more flexible and reusable.

Benefits of Using Cloudformation

Using CloudFormation simplifies the process of managing and provisioning your AWS infrastructure. By defining your infrastructure as code, you can version control your templates, track changes over time, and easily replicate environments across different AWS accounts and regions. CloudFormation also provides a rollback mechanism in case of deployment failures, helping to maintain the integrity of your infrastructure.

Limitations of Cloudformation

While CloudFormation is a powerful tool for managing AWS infrastructure, it does have some limitations. One common criticism is the learning curve associated with writing and understanding CloudFormation templates, especially for beginners. 

The JSON or YAML syntax can be complex, and debugging templates can be challenging. CloudFormation may not support all AWS resources or configurations, requiring workarounds or custom solutions in some cases.

Terraform: An Alternative to Cloudformation

Terraform is an open-source infrastructure as code tool created by HashiCorp. Like CloudFormation, Terraform allows you to define and provision infrastructure using declarative configuration files. Terraform is cloud-agnostic, meaning it can be used to manage resources not only on AWS but also on other cloud providers such as Azure, Google Cloud, and more.

Key Differences Between Terraform and Cloudformation

One of the main differences between Terraform and CloudFormation is their scope of support. While CloudFormation is tightly integrated with AWS services and features, Terraform provides a broader range of support for multi-cloud environments. Terraform also has a more user-friendly syntax compared to CloudFormation, making it easier for beginners to get started with infrastructure as code.

Choosing Between Terraform and Cloudformation

When deciding between Terraform and CloudFormation, consider factors such as your existing infrastructure, team expertise, and future scalability requirements. If your organization is heavily invested in AWS and requires deep integration with AWS services, CloudFormation may be the better choice. On the other hand, if you value multi-cloud support, simplicity of syntax, and a vibrant community, Terraform could be the right tool for your infrastructure management needs.

Zeet Terraform and Helm Product Overview

Complete Comparison of Terraform vs Cloudformation

developers understanding difference between Terraform vs Cloudformation

Terraform shines in efficiently managing and tracking the state of resources, making it a valuable asset in complex environments where resource dependencies are intricate. On the other hand, CloudFormation excels in automatically handling the state of resources within AWS environments, offering optimization specifically tailored for AWS resources. 

Learning Curve: Navigating the Path to Proficiency

When it comes to the learning curve, Terraform wins hearts with its HashiCorp Configuration Language (HCL), known for its readability and simplicity. Extensive documentation and a robust community support system contribute to its user-friendly environment. Conversely, CloudFormation utilizes JSON or YAML, which may be more familiar to AWS users; The AWS-specific configurations sometimes pose a steeper learning curve for beginners.

Performance and Scalability: Sizing Up Your Infrastructure

Both Terraform and CloudFormation are designed to handle large-scale infrastructure deployments efficiently. Terraform impresses with its ability to manage a vast number of resources seamlessly. On the other hand, CloudFormation is highly efficient within AWS environments, although meticulous template organization may be necessary for very large deployments to maintain optimal performance.

Multi-Cloud Support: Navigating the Cloud Ecosystem

Terraform emerges as the victor in multi-cloud support, allowing users to seamlessly work across different cloud providers, offering flexibility and avoiding vendor lock-in. In contrast, CloudFormation is tailored exclusively to AWS services, confining its use solely within the constraints of the AWS ecosystem.

Modularity: Building Blocks for Agile Infrastructure

Terraform supports modular design through modules that break down infrastructure into reusable code snippets. This flexibility and reusability significantly enhance development velocity. CloudFormation, while offering stack-like modules, falls short compared to Terraform's modular approach, limiting its adaptability and efficiency in complex infrastructures.

Code Syntax: Crafting Your Infrastructure Blueprint

Terraform adopts HCL as its primary language, which is fully compatible with JSON, offering a structured and intuitive syntax for infrastructure definition. Meanwhile, CloudFormation uses YAML or JSON for template creation, providing users with a more traditional approach that may feel familiar to those entrenched in AWS environments.

By diving into these key aspects of Terraform and CloudFormation, engineering teams can leverage a deeper understanding of their strengths and weaknesses to make informed decisions based on their specific infrastructure needs.

Best Practices for Maintaining Terraform vs Cloudformation Codebases In Large Scale Projects

illustration of a large scale project made with code blocks - Terraform vs Cloudformation

Infrastructure as Code (IaC) Principles

When working on large-scale projects with Terraform or CloudFormation, it is essential to adhere to Infrastructure as Code (IaC) principles. This includes treating infrastructure configurations as version-controlled code, enabling repeatability, consistency, and collaboration across teams.

Modularization and Reusability

In Terraform, modules play a crucial role in organizing code and promoting reusability. By breaking down infrastructure components into modular pieces, it becomes easier to manage changes and maintain consistency. CloudFormation also supports nested stacks for similar functionalities, allowing for the reuse of common templates across different parts of the infrastructure.

Environment Management

Utilize workspace functionality in Terraform to manage different environments such as development, staging, and production efficiently. This helps in isolating configurations and variables specific to each environment. In CloudFormation, parameterization and stack policies can be used to achieve similar environment management capabilities.

Dependency Management

In both Terraform and CloudFormation, understanding dependencies between resources is crucial for proper orchestration and provisioning. Terraform's graph-based execution automatically resolves dependencies, while CloudFormation requires explicit declaration of dependencies using the DependsOn attribute.

Testing and Validation

Implement automated testing and validation strategies to catch errors early in the development cycle. Terraform allows for unit testing with tools like Terratest, while CloudFormation supports testing frameworks like cfn-nag for template validation.

Documentation and Comments

Maintain clear documentation and comments within your codebase to enhance readability and promote knowledge sharing among team members. Both Terraform and CloudFormation support inline comments, which can be used to explain complex logic or configurations.

Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment (CI/CD)

Integrate your Terraform or CloudFormation codebase with CI/CD pipelines to automate builds, testing, and deployments. Tools like Terraform Cloud or AWS CodePipeline can help streamline the CI/CD process and ensure consistent delivery across environments.

Monitoring and Logging

Implement monitoring and logging solutions to track changes, detect drift, and troubleshoot issues in your infrastructure deployments. Leverage Terraform Enterprise's Sentinel policies or CloudFormation StackSets for centralized monitoring and governance.

Security and Compliance

Adhere to security best practices and compliance standards by incorporating security controls and compliance checks into your IaC pipelines. Use Terraform's Sentinel policies or CloudFormation StackSets with AWS Config Rules to enforce security and compliance requirements.

Team Collaboration

Facilitate collaboration among team members by using version control systems like Git, code reviews, and collaborative tools. Establish clear guidelines for code reviews, pull requests, and issue tracking to ensure alignment and consistency within the codebase.

Training and Knowledge Sharing

Invest in training programs and knowledge-sharing sessions to upskill team members on Terraform or CloudFormation best practices. Encourage continuous learning and experimentation to keep up with evolving IaC trends and technologies.

Related Reading

How To Successfully Implement Terraform vs Cloudformation

illustration of successful implementation of Terraform vs Cloudformation

Before delving into the implementation details of Terraform vs CloudFormation, it is crucial to understand the fundamental differences between the two. Terraform is an open-source infrastructure as code software tool created by HashiCorp, while CloudFormation is a service provided by AWS for defining and deploying infrastructure as code in AWS environments. 

Both tools serve the same purpose of managing infrastructure as code, but they have different syntax, capabilities, and ecosystems. Terraform follows a declarative approach, while CloudFormation is imperative.

Choosing the Right Tool for the Job: Considerations for Implementation

When deciding whether to implement Terraform or CloudFormation, several factors need to be considered. These include the complexity of your infrastructure, existing skill sets within your team, the cloud provider you are using, and the level of customization and flexibility required. 

Terraform is known for its multi-cloud support, enabling you to manage infrastructure across different cloud providers, while CloudFormation is tightly integrated with AWS services, providing seamless deployment within AWS environments.

Getting Started with Terraform: Best Practices for Implementation

Implementing Terraform successfully involves following best practices to ensure security, scalability, and maintainability. Begin by defining your infrastructure as code in Terraform configuration files, using modules for reusable components, and leveraging state management to track changes. 

Secure sensitive information using environment variables or a secret management tool, and regularly update Terraform versions to benefit from new features and security patches. Test your Terraform code using automated testing frameworks to catch errors early in the development lifecycle.

Navigating CloudFormation: Key Steps for Seamless Implementation

For a successful CloudFormation implementation, start by writing templates that define your AWS resources and their configurations. Use parameters to make your templates reusable and customizable, and leverage mappings for dynamic values. 

Implement stack policies to control updates to your resources and monitor your stacks using CloudFormation StackSets for multi-account deployments. Ensure IAM roles and policies are properly configured to grant necessary permissions to CloudFormation for resource provisioning.

Security and Compliance: Ensuring a Secure Implementation

Regardless of whether you choose Terraform or CloudFormation, security should be a top priority during implementation. Follow security best practices such as least privilege access, encryption of sensitive data, and regular audits of your infrastructure code. 

Implement compliance checks using tools like AWS Config or Terraform Sentinel to enforce security policies and prevent misconfigurations. Regularly review and update your infrastructure code to address security vulnerabilities and maintain a secure environment.

Scaling for Success: Planning for Growth and Scalability

As your infrastructure grows, scalability becomes a key consideration in your implementation strategy. With Terraform, use workspaces to manage multiple environments and modules to scale your infrastructure codebase. 

Leverage Terraform Cloud for remote state management and collaboration across teams. In CloudFormation, use nested stacks or stack sets for managing complex deployments and scaling across multiple AWS accounts. Monitor your infrastructure performance and adjust your templates to accommodate growth while maintaining efficiency.

Monitoring and Maintenance: Ensuring Long-Term Success

After successfully implementing Terraform or CloudFormation, ongoing monitoring and maintenance are crucial for long-term success. Set up logging and monitoring for your infrastructure resources to detect and respond to any issues proactively. 

Regularly review and update your infrastructure code to incorporate new features, security patches, and infrastructure changes. Conduct periodic assessments of your implementation to identify opportunities for optimization and enhancement, ensuring your infrastructure remains secure, scalable, and efficient.

Zeet Contact Us

Have Successful Releases Every Time With Zeet's CI/CD & Deployment Platform for Kubernetes and Terraform

Zeet is a game-changer when it comes to optimizing your cloud deployments, whether you are leveraging Terraform or Cloudformation. By utilizing Zeet's CI/CD & deployment platform, your engineering team can streamline the deployment process and ensure seamless cloud deployments every time. Zeet empowers your team to maximize the benefits of your cloud investments by providing a robust platform that simplifies and accelerates the deployment of infrastructure as code.

With Zeet, your engineering team can become top-performing individual contributors, enhancing their skills and efficiency when working with Terraform or Cloudformation. Zeet's platform not only ensures efficient deployments but also fosters a culture of continuous improvement within your team, making them stronger contributors to your organization's success. Reach out to Zeet today to unlock the full potential of your cloud, Kubernetes, and infrastructure investments, and witness the transformation of your engineering team into a high-performing unit.

Related Reading

Subscribe to Changelog newsletter

Jack from the Zeet team shares DevOps & SRE learnings, top articles, and new Zeet features in a twice-a-month newsletter.

Thank you!

Your submission has been processed
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.